Ebe66
Aktives Mitglied
- Registriert
- 11 Februar 2023
- Beiträge
- 185
- Reaktionspunkte
- 327
@spclzd
Without further checking, just based on the filename, that would be the file I mean yes.
But, regional differences aside, this will probably indicate something was wrong with the "key/tags to keep filter".
Checking https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/keys/shelter gives this:
With as tag =yes
So there should be loads and loads (but again, could be a regional difference)
Using this site for overpass turbo (no limits) https://maps.mail.ru/osm/tools/overpass/ I get a pretty reasonable result at first glance.
Even the clusters make sense when zooming in
A random test shows it would not fall under amenity=shelter. A bus stop as example
I wonder how it would work out in real life in your example, but it seems you know more about theme-ing than me
If I feel up to it, i'll try to add shelter=yes to my filter just to see what happens although I have a pretty good idea why it doesn't work for you.
Just for arguments sake: You probably are still using 2 filter sets/files one with tags to keep with name and one to keep without name. In that case you could be running into something that took me some time to figure out.
If a node for example with shelter=yes is kept in the no name file because it's also part of a way and the same node is also being part of the with names file because the bus stop has a name, than when these two files are merged again the info from a node is not merged but either the info from the no names OR the info from the with names file ends up in the resulting file.
Without further checking, just based on the filename, that would be the file I mean yes.
But, regional differences aside, this will probably indicate something was wrong with the "key/tags to keep filter".
Checking https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/keys/shelter gives this:
With as tag =yes
So there should be loads and loads (but again, could be a regional difference)
Using this site for overpass turbo (no limits) https://maps.mail.ru/osm/tools/overpass/ I get a pretty reasonable result at first glance.
Even the clusters make sense when zooming in
A random test shows it would not fall under amenity=shelter. A bus stop as example
I wonder how it would work out in real life in your example, but it seems you know more about theme-ing than me
If I feel up to it, i'll try to add shelter=yes to my filter just to see what happens although I have a pretty good idea why it doesn't work for you.
Just for arguments sake: You probably are still using 2 filter sets/files one with tags to keep with name and one to keep without name. In that case you could be running into something that took me some time to figure out.
If a node for example with shelter=yes is kept in the no name file because it's also part of a way and the same node is also being part of the with names file because the bus stop has a name, than when these two files are merged again the info from a node is not merged but either the info from the no names OR the info from the with names file ends up in the resulting file.